The dream is bold: to elevate Kenya from a lower-middle-income nation to a first-world country within a generation. President Ruto’s confidence is infectious, calling for 4 trillion shillings in investment across infrastructure, energy, and agriculture. It is a vision every Kenyan should embrace, but the gap between ambition and reality—especially concerning execution, debt, and governance—is immense.
Advertisement
Let’s break down the vision, analyzing what could work, what is likely pure political rhetoric, and what might never come to fruition.
What Defines a “First World” Country?
When politicians speak of a first-world country, they are talking about more than just roads and airports. It’s a country where the entire system works for everyone.
1. High Income per Capita
-
The Benchmark: The World Bank classifies a country as high-income when the average person earns around $14,000 USD per year.
-
Kenya’s Reality: Kenya’s current average is approximately $2,000 USD per year. Achieving the first-world benchmark means the average income must grow nearly sevenfold.
2. A Producer, Not Just a Buyer
A developed economy makes and sells things. It adds value to its raw resources.
-
The Goal: Manufacturing should contribute 20% to 25% of GDP.
-
Kenya’s Reality: Kenya’s manufacturing sector has shrunk to only about 7% of GDP. The country still exports raw goods (tea, coffee, minerals) and imports the finished products at triple the price.
3. Strong and Trustworthy Systems
This refers to institutions that function effectively: excellent healthcare, schools that prepare youth for the job market, honest courts, and police who protect without bribery. Kenya, despite improvements, still loses billions annually to corruption and experiences constant delays in major government projects.
4. Human Development
A truly developed nation scores high on the Human Development Index (HDI).
-
The Metrics: People live longer, healthier lives, children complete school, and maternal mortality is low.
-
Kenya’s Reality: Kenya ranks around 150th globally on the HDI, far from the top tier.
Pillar 1: Infrastructure, Energy, and Food Security
The dream requires a massive injection of 4$ trillion shillings, primarily for these sectors.
Food Security: The 50 Mega-Dams Plan
Ruto proposes 50 mega-dams to irrigate 2 million new acres of farmland, tripling the current capacity ($670,000 acres). The goal is to end hunger and shift the country from importing to exporting food.
-
The Cost: This is estimated to require nearly 1 trillion shillings for dams and irrigation alone.
-
The Reality Check: Kenya’s current public debt is around 12 trillion shillings, with over half of every collected tax shilling going to debt servicing. Previous flagship water projects, like the Arror and Kimwarer dams, were plagued by multi-billion shilling scandals and remain unfinished. The money for this ambitious, costly, and necessary plan is simply not available without massive private sector involvement or further unsustainable borrowing.
Infrastructure & Energy: The Debt Trap
The plan is to complete the Standard Gauge Railway (SGR) to Malaba (390 billion shillings) and expand electricity generation to 10,000 megawatts (tripling capacity).
-
The SGR: The first phase to Naivasha cost 480 billion shillings and is struggling to break even. Adding another phase risks ballooning the debt even further without a clear guarantee of economic returns.
-
The Energy Paradox: Kenya is a renewable energy leader (geothermal, wind), but its power is one of the most expensive in Africa. An industrial user pays 11 to 12 shillings per kilowatt-hour, nearly double the cost in competitors like Egypt. Having enough power is useless if factories cannot afford to run their machines.
The risk here is clear: more debt-funded mega-projects that are beautiful but unsustainable, further eroding the nation’s financial breathing room.
Pillar 2: Industrialization and Manufacturing
This is the most critical component. No country becomes first world by exporting raw materials.
Ruto’s plan focuses on making Kenya a regional manufacturing hub by establishing Special Economic Zones (SEZs) and industrial parks in key areas like Naivasha and Dongo Kundu. These zones are meant to attract investors with tax breaks, cheap electricity, and streamlined licensing.
-
The Model: This model worked for Singapore, South Korea, and Ethiopia.
-
The Sticking Point: Despite 40 billion shillings allocated in the 2023/2024 budget, most county-based industrial parks remain on paper due to a lack of funding, land disputes, and bureaucracy. Flagship projects like Dongo Kundu (near Mombasa) are years behind schedule, with only basic infrastructure near completion and no factories running yet.
The Basics Must Work
Industrialization will fail unless the government addresses three core issues:
Advertisement
-
Power Costs: Substantially reduce the cost of electricity for industrial users.
-
Tax Instability: Ensure consistent and predictable tax policies. Businesses cannot plan for 10 years when rules change every budget cycle.
-
Bureaucracy: Simplify the licensing process, which currently requires up to 11 different approvals to start a factory.
Pillar 3: Human Development (Education, Health, Housing)
Ruto correctly identifies that people build the nation, not just buildings.
Education: The Shift to TVETs
The goal is to shift from a degree-obsessed nation to a skills-driven economy by expanding Technical and Vocational Education and Training (TVETs).
-
The Intention: Excellent, mirroring the successful models of Germany and South Korea.
-
The Challenge: Many TVETs lack modern equipment, and graduates struggle to find jobs because industrial growth has not kept pace with the number of skilled workers being produced.
Healthcare: The Social Health Insurance Fund (SHIF)
SHIF replaces NHIF with the noble goal of giving every Kenyan access to quality care without the risk of poverty.
-
The Reality: The rollout has faced massive public mistrust and misunderstanding. More fundamentally, the budget for health is critically low (barely 8% of what the WHO recommends). New laws won’t fix the fact that county hospitals are understocked, underfunded, and doctors are constantly on strike.
Affordable Housing
The plan is to build 200,000 units annually, funded by the contentious Affordable Housing Levy deducted from salaries.
-
The Public Anger: The levy has collected over 35 billion shillings, but the projects are largely still underway, facing legal challenges. Furthermore, the units, priced between 1 million and 3 million shillings, are unaffordable for the majority of citizens who are paying the levy, many of whom earn less than 30,000 a month. If the people funding the housing cannot qualify to buy it, the levy is seen not as development but as a wealth transfer.
The Singapore Obsession: A Brutal Comparison
Ruto constantly references Singapore, citing its miraculous transformation from a poor island to a global powerhouse. While the ambition is commendable, the comparison often skips the brutal reality of how Singapore was built.
| Singapore’s Founding Principles | Kenya’s Reality |
| Zero-Tolerance Corruption: Ministers and civil servants were jailed, not merely transferred. | Corruption is normalized, and massive scandals reoccur every few years, often with no high-profile convictions. |
| Long-Term Planning: Policies were set for 20-50 years, transcending political cycles. | Planning is done in 5-year election cycles, with new administrations abandoning old projects to rebrand new ones. |
| Meritocracy: Jobs and positions were based purely on skill, not tribal or political connections. | The public service is often criticized for political and ethnic appointments over competence. |
| Accountability: Public funds had clear outcomes, and projects were finished on time with penalties for failure. | Projects stall, costs are inflated, and contractors walk out, often finding new tenders elsewhere. |
| Truly Affordable Housing: Built over 1 million homes in 20 years that every citizen could afford. | The housing levy is collected, but the resulting units are priced out of reach for the majority of the working class. |
“If you want to defeat corruption, you must be prepared to send your friends to jail.” – Lee Kuan Yew
Until Kenya adopts this level of political discipline and integrity, referencing Singapore is merely a campaign slogan, not a blueprint.
The Bottom Line: Mindset Over Money
Ruto’s vision is arguably the most ambitious blueprint a Kenyan leader has presented. It is not impossible.
-
What Could Work: Value addition, industrial parks, and the focus on technical skills are the right economic levers.
-
What Won’t Work: Continuing to borrow its way to prosperity, collecting levies for “affordable” projects that the majority cannot afford, and comparing itself to a disciplined nation without adopting its discipline.
The biggest barrier is not the 4 trillion shillings—it is the third-world working ethic and mindset. Kenya must adopt a culture that:
-
Finishes What It Starts: No more half-done roads, incomplete dams, and ghost projects.
-
Rewards Competence: Not connections or tribal affiliations.
-
Punishes Corruption: Making accountability normal, not shocking.
A nation becomes first-world not by the number of skyscrapers it erects, but by how many lives it genuinely lifts out of poverty, and by ensuring its systems are trustworthy, efficient, and honest.